Oh I do have ideas... probably not all practical to transpose into DS. I'll just list them and you can see if you consider them as a realistic option. :D
Assuming that these condoms have volume to them, to make it a complete set:
- A wrapper that's been ripped open (and empty)
- A condom without its wrapper but still not unrolled (the logical next step)
- Upping the ante: a used condom with the end tied up and/or not, possibly d-force capable so that we can make them look discarded with negligence.
- A really hard tall order would be that used condom with a tied end, a filled tip, that can be tucked in a bikini or panties side string as a kind
of "counting coups" trophy.
When it comes to condoms, that's all that comes to mind here,
"That was fun. Let's do it again."